I agreed, in a phone conversation with an editor, to come up with 3 rough sketches of a typical NH cartoonist. When I got off the phone, I realized I didn't know what one visual of that idea would be, much less the three I promised
Hmm. New Hampshire. What says "New Hampshire?" I came up with a handful of ideas:
- Old Man of the Mountain monument
- Moose
- Maple syrup
- Foliage
So, I drew up the Old Man of the Mountain, falling on a cartoonist. As you can see, the cartoonist is holding up one of those dinky Wile E. Coyote umbrellas for protection.
And then I drew a moose-as-cartoonist, drawing with maple syrup.
And, finally, more of a gag cartoon: a cartoonist and his wife and the foliage.
Which one would you choose? I'll let you know which one the editor picked later.
My thanks to Chris Lupetti who suggested I show these.
#3 is the winner conceptually - it would be a great color gag! - though the dinky umbrella in #1 is great. Hmmm ...
ReplyDeleteYep, #3, is a great idea. the others leave me a little flat.
ReplyDeleteI hate to jump on any bandwagon, but count me in for #3. It seems to capture what you're after.
ReplyDeleteHi Mike - I have to go with #2. The moose at the drawing table, inking with maple syrup, captures the "typical New Hampshire cartoonist" in a completely fun way.
ReplyDeleteDan
Beyer
Thanks, Guys. I'll post the one the editor chose in a while. My only hint was that she didn't choose the one I thought she was going to.
ReplyDeleteI'm guessing number 3.
ReplyDeleteGotta be the moose!
ReplyDeleteI am going for the moose as well, as the most readable of the three. Add some foliage if you will.
ReplyDeleteMike --
ReplyDeleteI daresay you left out a couple of key archetypes to differentiate NH from its Northern New England neighbors; specifically:
-- Cheap Bastard
-- Rusty truck
-- Woodpile
Mike, I love all of them! The #3 is great for any state. But, I especially love that the moose is left handed and has to curl his hoof around! Great drawings. You are so good .
ReplyDeleteI lived in NH for 40 years and I'd have a hard time imagining a NH cartoonist. A great resource would be Mike Marland's RFD strip, filled with trucks and tourists, black flies and mud season.
ReplyDeleteI don't think of the moose as being especially NH -- that's more of a Maine thing -- and the fallen face of the Old Men is, I bet, something few like to think about. So I'll predict that the editor went with the leaf cartoon.
I am voting for #3! I think it's very funny and is sharp. Great jobs on all your cartoons.
ReplyDelete... And the winner is here:
ReplyDeletehttp://mikelynchcartoons.blogspot.com/2008/11/cartoonists-in-hippo.html